- “Nah, come on. Lets do it old school.”— Dr. Townshend
"My Brother, My Keeper" is the fourteenth episode of Scrubs' second season. Turk's brother Kevin visits him at the hospital and Turk tries to use him as a good reason for Carla to accept his proposal. J.D. is partnered with a well loved doctor, Dr. Townshend and his 'old school' methodology. Dr. Cox, against Jordan's wishes, tries to find the sex of her baby, which results in Elliot gaining leverage.
Carla & Turk
Turk's brother Kevin comes to visit. Turk just asked Carla to marry him and she said, that she needs to think about it. Turk shows Carla Kevin's kids, hoping to convince her to say yes. Then Kevin admits that he divorced his wife, not helping Turk's idea. Later, Kevin admits to Turk that his wife divorced him. Turk goes to the bar to have a drink with his brother to comfort him. However, they come back with Turk completely drunk and a beautiful woman who is carrying Rowdy, causing Carla to storm out of the apartment.
J.D. meets Dr. Townshend
Dr. Townshend, the friendly old colleague of Dr. Kelso, comes to the hospital and J.D. is paired with him to work on a patient. He advises J.D. to do an "old school" procedure on a patient, even though it is dangerous. During this procedure, J.D. accidentally nicks the patient's carotid artery but Dr. Townshend says he will take the blame. J.D. walks into Dr. Kelso's office and tells him that he nicked the artery, but only because Dr. Townshend told him to do an outdated and dangerous procedure. Dr. Townshend admits that he does not attend the seminars about new medical procedures and Dr. Kelso is forced to fire him, even though he is his best friend.
The Baby's Gender
Meanwhile, Dr. Gerson performs an ultrasound on Jordan's stomach and asks her and Perry if they want to know the gender of the baby. Jordan speaks for both of them that they don't, but Elliot walks in and sees. Dr. Cox then tries to get her to reveal it, but she uses it as leverage. In the end Elliot gave it to Jordan in a sealed envelope. Jordan told Dr. Cox that she doesn't want to know it, but if he must know that he can look, but she would be disappointed. He crumples it up and throws it away and remains unknowing.
- J.D. removes a knife from Dr. Townshend's back.
- J.D. slaps a patient, Mrs. Francis for not getting up when he asks her to and they have a slapping contest, before Dr. Townshend grabs Mrs. Francis and convinces J.D. to "give her one in the gut". (Deleted scene)
Dr. Townshend tells Janitor to be nice to J.D.. He gets a group of people (an early version of the Brain Trust) who are workers in the hospital (Brent from parking, Crazy-Eyes Margo, and Troy), and tells J.D. they will help him. After J.D. tells Dr. Kelso that Dr. Townshend forced him to perform an outdated procedure, Janitor blames J.D. for Dr. Townshend getting fired. In the end, the group flips over J.D.'s car.
Episode Running Gags
- J.D. bets that if Carla doesn't say yes to Turk's proposal, he'll power-walk naked through the hospital singing "Me and Bobby McGee." After losing the bet, he pays Todd to do it for him.
- Dr. Kelso keeps subtly calling J.D. ugly.
- Dick Van Dyke as Doug Townshend
- D.L. Hughley as Kevin Turk
- Robert Beckwith as Roy
- Julie Hudson as Ginny Gerson
- Paul Perry as Randall
- Joe Rose as Troy
- George Miserlis as Crispin
- Charles Chun as Phillip Wen
- "Hello My Baby" written by Ida Emerson & Joseph E. Howard (Performed by The Blanks)
- "Gone" by Tart
- "Me & Bobby McGee" by Janis Joplin (Performed by Robert Maschio)
- "My Fault" by Keren DeBerg
- "Bulletproof Glow" by Avion
- "He Ain't Heavy, He's My Brother" originally by the Hollies (Performed by D.L. Hughley)
- “Oh well, back in '68, I don't like you, the end.”— Dr. Kelso
- “At the least I feel I'm interesting looking.”— J.D.
- The patient that J.D. performs the outdated procedure on is actually Dr. Beardfacé.
- Dr. Cox didn't know Elliot's last name until this episode.
- The fantasy in which J.D. pulls the knife from Dr. Townshend's back had originally been written to take place between him and Turk in season one's "My Day Off."
- In this fantasy, the seam where the knife sheaths inside itself (to look like it's in Dr. Townsend's back) is visible.
- In this episode, the Janitor tells J.D. that "Crazy Eyes Margot" is going to make sure that J.D. gets freshly-pressed scrubs in his locker every morning. However, in "My Sacrificial Clam", it is stated that the medical staff get their scrubs from the "scrubs machine".
- This is first episode Dr. Kelso shows any kind of commiseration to another person.
- In the scene with J.D. and Dr. Kelso, Dr. Kelso's patient chart is visibly a white piece of paper written on instead of a real hospital chart.
- When the Janitor falls off the roof, it takes him more than 5 seconds to fall. This couldn't be because the ladder's end was almost at J.D.'s height.
- Kevin calls J.D. "Alfalfa", who is a character from Little Rascals.
- Turk describes his couch as "fit for a king". Turk's brother, Kevin, is played by D.L. Hughley who starred in The Original Kings Of Comedy.
- Kevin saying "He ain't heavy... he's my brother!" is a reference to the 1969 song He Ain't Heavy, He's My Brother, by The Hollies.
- When Elliot says "Well, girls can play baseball, too", Dr. Cox replies "Oh, yak-yak-yak-yak, I know what girls can do! You've come a long way, baby." "You've come a long way, baby" was the slogan for a women's-only cigarette produced by Virginia Slims. The slogan stated that women have come a long way in life, just like, in Dr. Cox's rant, women have come a long way in sports.
- The title refers to a saying from the Bible's story of Cain and Abel. After Cain murdered his brother, Abel, God asked him where his brother was. Cain answered "I know not; am I my brother's keeper?". The saying means that people have the responsibility to watch out and care for one another, similar to the way Kevin has Turk's back at times, and doesn't at other times.